These 10 Rare Bicentennial Quarter Are Worth $250 million Each — Still in circulation

In 1976, the U.S. Mint released the Bicentennial Quarter to celebrate America’s 200th anniversary. With its iconic drummer boy reverse design and dual date of 1776–1976, it quickly became a staple of American pocket change. Most of these quarters are worth only face value—but some rare versions, featuring mint errors, silver content, or high grades, have commanded staggering sums, including rumors of coins worth up to $250 million.

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just curious about the change in your jar, here’s what you need to know about these elusive and highly valuable Bicentennial Quarters.

The Top 10 Most Valuable Bicentennial Quarters

Below is a breakdown of the rarest and most valuable Bicentennial Quarters, and what makes them stand out:

No.	Type of Rare Bicentennial Quarter	Estimated Value
1	$250 Million Error Quarter	$250 million (rumored)
2	Double Die Obverse Quarter	$69 million+
3	Off-Center Strike Quarter	$200,000+
4	Overstruck Bicentennial Quarter	$250,000+
5	Silver Proof Bicentennial Quarter	$15,000+
6	1976-S Silver MS69	$19,200
7	1976-D Clad MS68	$6,462.50
8	1976 Clad MS67+	$1,821
9	1976-S Clad PR67	$6,038
10	1976-S Silver PR	$13,500

Let’s dig deeper into what makes these coins worth more than just twenty-five cents.

1. The $250 Million Error Bicentennial Quarter

Though unverified, stories of a mysterious Bicentennial Quarter fetching $250 million have circulated in numismatic circles and online forums. The coin is said to feature a catastrophic minting error, possibly involving the wrong planchet, double striking, or composition anomalies. No such coin has been publicly authenticated—but if it exists, it would likely be the most valuable U.S. coin ever minted.

2. Double Die Obverse Quarter

This rare error occurs when the coin die imprints the design twice in slightly different positions, creating a visible doubling effect, especially in the date or lettering. Some examples of this Bicentennial Quarter have been claimed to sell for over $69 million, although more commonly they trade in the thousands to low millions, depending on visibility and condition.

3. Off-Center Strike Quarter

These occur when the planchet (coin blank) is misaligned during striking, resulting in a design that is shifted. The more dramatic the error, the higher the value—especially when critical design elements are still visible. Top examples have gone for over $200,000.

4. Overstruck Bicentennial Quarter

An overstruck coin is one that’s accidentally struck on top of another coin—possibly a dime, nickel, or even foreign coin. These are incredibly rare and visually stunning, often commanding prices above $250,000 for their uniqueness.

5. Silver Proof Bicentennial Quarter

Minted specifically for collectors, these quarters contain 40% silver instead of the usual copper-nickel composition. Found in 1976 special mint sets, high-grade examples in pristine condition have sold for $15,000 or more.

6. 1976-S Silver MS69 Quarter

Struck at the San Francisco Mint, this near-perfect silver specimen graded MS69 (Mint State 69) sold for $19,200 at auction. Just one point shy of a perfect MS70, it reflects exceptional preservation and strike quality.

7. 1976-D Clad MS68 Quarter

This Denver-minted clad coin in MS68 grade is among the highest graded examples of its kind. With so many coins being circulated, finding one in such immaculate condition is rare, leading to a sale price of $6,462.50.

8. 1976 Clad MS67+ Regular Strike Quarter

Even though this is a standard issue used in circulation, an MS67+ grade pushes its market value up. With so many quarters exposed to daily wear, finding one in such top-tier condition is tough. One such coin fetched $1,821 at auction.

9. 1976-S Clad PR67 Quarter

This San Francisco-minted proof is valued for its sharp strike and mirrored finish. In PR67 condition, these coins offer great value for collectors, selling for over $6,000 in some cases.

10. 1976-S Silver PR Quarter

Another San Francisco product, this silver proof features a crisp finish and was not intended for circulation. In top grades, it can command up to $13,500 or more, particularly among silver coin investors.

Could These Still Be in Circulation?

Here’s the exciting part—some of these coins may still be out there. While the high-grade proofs and MS coins were generally kept in collections, error coins like double dies, off-center strikes, or overstrikes could theoretically still be floating around in pocket change or old rolls from the bank.

That’s why collectors are still combing through their quarters. Finding one of these rarities could mean a life-changing payday.

FAQs